1-5-18: With the new tax laws should I keep my Home Equity Line of Credit
Question of the week: With the new tax laws should I keep my Home Equity Line of Credit?
Answer: With the calendar turning to 2018 we are now under the new tax codes signed into law by President Trump in December. There is still plenty of confusion about how the IRS will treat many of the changes, among them is the interest paid by home owners if they have a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) and if it is deductible on the federal tax return. Reading through many articles and communicating with tax professionals, lenders that specialize in HELOCs and other research I am not entirely clear on how HELOC interest will be treated moving forward—and until the IRS issues a clear ruling I don’t think anyone else is either.
Some people may use the deduction, or lack thereof, to determine how they wish to move forward with their current HELOC, or to obtain one for purposes of home improvement, debt consolidation, college costs, etc. Here are some items to consider if you have, or are considering, a HELOC.
DISCLAIMER: I am not a tax professional, if you have a HELOC please consult with your tax preparer regarding the impact it has on your taxes.
There is a lot of information out that none of the interest on your HELOC will be deductible, regardless of when you obtained it or how the funds were spent (home improvement, debt consolidation, medical expenses, college, etc). Under this line of reasoning, if you have a $100,000 HELOC you obtained when you purchased the home in 2011, the interest is no longer deductible.
However, there are some “experts” that are stating that if your HELOC was used for the acquisition of your primary, or second/vacation home, then the interest paid on the HELOC is still deductible. These are contrary opinions, and if you have a HELOC that you have only used to purchase your home it obviously has an impact on your tax preparation in the future. If acquisition HELOCs will remain deductible then you are fine and continue as you have in the past, if they are not then you will want to meet with your tax and mortgage professionals to determine your best course of action moving forward.
If you obtained a HELOC to put in a pool, remodel your home or do other home improvements, in the past you probably had an interest deduction. Under the new law, based on almost everything I have read and heard, you will no longer be able to deduct that interest from your federal taxes.
If you have a HELOC that you used for medical expenses, college tuition and/or debt consolidation you will also not be able to deduct the interest moving forward.
Back to our question of the week, if you have a HELOC should you keep it? Especially if the interest you pay is no longer deductible?
As with most questions involving mortgages and personal finances, there is no standard answer for everyone. The factors you need to consider are:
How much is the tax deduction you are losing? If you have a balance of $50,000 and are paying $2500 per year in interest, is losing that deduction costing you a lot of money?
What are your options to pay off the HELOC? Do you have cash or assets you can liquidate to pay off the balance? If you do what is your trade off? What has been your return on investment for those assets and what is the rate on your HELOC? Are you making more in interest and/or dividend payments than you are paying for the HELOC?
Or perhaps you pay off the HELOC with a refinance of your primary mortgage and consolidate the two loans. Once again, we do the math, what is your current rate on your primary mortgage, what are your payments, what is the value of your home and the total balances we would be consolidating? And finally, and very importantly, what will be your new rate of interest and monthly payment?
One big factor to consider if you have a HELOC and are considering paying off or refinancing to consolidate the payment is your future interest rates. Almost every HELOC has its interest rate tied to the prime rate. The prime rate tends to move up and down when the Federal Reserve moves its lending rate up and down. In the past year the Fed has hiked its rates three times, each time 0.25% (one-quarter of one percent), resulting in the prime rate also going up 0.25% three times for a total of 0.75% (three-quarters of one percent) in the past year. If you had a $100,000 HELOC in December 2016 and retained the same balance through the year your interest payment at the end of 2017 was $62.50 per month ($750 per year) more. The Fed has announced it intends to increase rates three more times in 2018, which will increase the rate on your HELOC another 0.75%.
With increases in the prime rate known to be coming in 2018, does it make sense to fix the rate on your HELOC balance and consolidate it with your primary loan?
When making a decision regarding your HELOC keep in mind the tax laws started on Monday, and the longer you wait to make that decision the more impact it could have on your tax returns for 2018 that you will file in 2019.
When you meet with your tax professional to prepare your 2017 taxes if you have a HELOC ask for advice about your interest deduction options for 2018. And before you meet with your tax professional do not hesitate to give me a call to discuss your options if refinancing and consolidating your HELOC is an option for you.
Should you keep your HELOC? Maybe, maybe not, but do your research and explore your options, contact me to discuss some of those options.
Have a question? Ask me!
The final employment report for 2017 was released this week showing the economy added 148,000 jobs in December and the unemployment rate was steady at 4.1%. The total hires in December were down from November and below expectations of those economists polled. A positive news in the report was a 0.3% increase hourly earnings from December, up 2.5% from December 2016. With inflation running below 2%, average wages increasing more than 2% is positive for workers. Within the report there was strength in construction and manufacturing hires and there are signs that scarcity of skilled labor in these sectors could be hindering growth. Overall the news is mortgage rate neutral.
Rates for Friday January 5, 2018: Ending our first week of the new year rates continue the steady pattern of the last few months with no change from last Friday’s rates. Conforming rates start 2018 one-quarter of one percent below (0.25%) what they were the first Friday on 2017.
FIXED RATE MORTGAGES AT COST OF 1.25 POINTS LOCKED FOR 45 DAYS:
30 year conforming 3.75% Flat
30 year high-balance conforming 3.875% Flat
Please note that these are base rates and adjustments may be added for condominiums, refinances, credit scores, loan to value, no impound account and period rate is locked. Rates are based on 20% down with 740 FICO score for purchase mortgages.
Today’s WR&MU is being composed from Palm Desert where the Smith family has been compounded for the week. I will admit to feeling no guilt as we have enjoyed very enjoyable weather, getting in a few rounds of golf and spells by the pool, as other parts of the country are digging out of their front doors and wondering which mound of snow in the street is their car. California is not flawless, with perhaps the exception of weather throughout the year and especially weeks like this.
I hope everyone had a wonderful New Year’s celebration and wish you all a very healthy and prosperous 2018!
Dennis
